Jakob Nielsen Film Reviewing Method
He isn't usually known as a film buff, but Jakob Nielsen has been reviewing films for quite a while now:
Newsgroups: rec.arts.sf.tv Path: sparky!uunet!walter!hip10.bellcore.com!nielsen From: Jakob Nielsen <niel...@bellcore.com> Subject: Re: Time Trax Message-ID: <1993Jan21.185126.27016@walter.bellcore.com> X-Xxmessage-Id: <A78459A5F4010...@hip10.bellcore.com> X-Xxdate: Thu, 21 Jan 93 18:46:13 GMT Sender: n...@walter.bellcore.com Nntp-Posting-Host: hip10.bellcore.com Organization: Bellcore - Bell Communications Research X-Useragent: Nuntius v1.1.1d17 References: <1993Jan21.112231.6098@sol.UVic.CA> <1993Jan21.181355.23099@cs.tulane.edu> Distribution: na Date: Thu, 21 Jan 93 18:51:26 GMT Lines: 17 In article <1993Jan21.112231.6...@sol.UVic.CA> Michael McAleese, mmcal...@cs16.UVic.CA writes: > After viewing the two hour debut movie of Time Trax, I have to give > it the old thumbs down. It wasn't exactly that it was bad... it just > wasn't good. There were also several errors showing lack of care in production. The worst (given its prominence) was probably the sign saying "Smithsonian Institute" when in fact it is called the "Smithsonian Institution". Another error (that admittedly might only be caught by a Scandinavian) is the scene where somebody gets the Nobel prize in physics and the diploma reads "Awarded by the Norwegian Nobel committee." The Norwegian Nobel committee only awards the peace price, whereas the other prizes are awarded by the *Swedish* Nobel committee. -- Jakob Nielsen, niel...@bellcore.com, fax (201) 829-2645 Bellcore, MRE 2P-370, 445 South St., Morristown, NJ 09792-1910, USA
He also reveals how he selects films for his viewing pleasure:
Path: gmdzi!unido!mcsun!uunet!wuarchive!zaphod.mps.ohio-state.edu!ub!rutgers!bellcore-2!bellcore!nielsen From: niel...@flash.bellcore.com (Jakob Nielsen) Newsgroups: soc.culture.nordic Subject: Re: TV/radio Message-ID: <NIELSEN.90Oct26132631@breeze.flash.bellcore.com> Date: 26 Oct 90 17:26:31 GMT References: <1990Oct23.211038.23224@ida.liu.se> Sender: n...@bellcore.bellcore.com Organization: /u/nielsen/.organization Lines: 15 Posted: Fri Oct 26 18:26:31 1990 In-reply-to: uda@IDA.LiU.SE's message of 23 Oct 90 21:10:38 GMT In fact, one can do even better with American TV than mentioned by most posters if one has a VCR. Many of the better movies are shown after midnight (ideal for hackers :-) and I have collected about 10 films on tape during a period of about 3 months which I have simply not had time to watch. (this is in addition to whatever films and shows I saw in realtime or soon after they were broadcast). When I lived in Denmark, my algorithm for whether it was worth taping a film from TV was whether it had at least two stars in Halliwel's film guide (scale of 0-4 stars). Now I don't even tape all the three-star films. -- Jakob Nielsen, Bellcore MRE-2P370, 445 South St, Morristown, NJ 07962-1910, USA niel...@bellcore.com, Tel. (201) 829-4731(w)/538-7254(h), Fax (201) 538-9093.


I have a suggestion that I hope you take to heart. Prove to the
world that you understand what it takes to provide the world with good
design. Prove that you understand that good design, especially as it
pertains to the field of high-technology product design, is also about
nuts and bolts, honest, straight-forward usability. Prove to the
designers out there you understand the principles of good design by
tackling your own little spot on the world wide web.
